Diesel Fuel Alternatives Being Explored by Construction Industry

Equipment manufacturers are making investments in various fuel alternatives for powering heavy machinery as it becomes less viable to rely solely on diesel

Diesel Fuel Alternatives Being Explored by Construction Industry

Interested in Excavation?

Get Excavation articles, news and videos right in your inbox! Sign up now.

Excavation + Get Alerts

Diesel has powered construction equipment for decades. But due to increased costs in resource extraction, environmental concerns, regulatory limitations, social trends and other reasons, manufacturers are experimenting with other means of powering equipment.

Electric is popular for nonmobile, small mobile, indoor demolition, short-haul transportation and underground mining equipment, but it doesn’t meet the challenges for a lot of general construction applications.

In order to power large, mobile equipment in construction applications, manufacturers are investing in alternative fuel, such as natural gas, propane, biodiesel and hydrogen. 

Propane-Powered Equipment

Propane has been used to power pavers for a long time — not for environmental benefits or government regulations, but because it is more effective at heating asphalt. Natural gas has been used in trucks for a long time as well, and the introduction of new gasoline alternatives is meeting acceptance in construction applications.

For example, Bomag has designed the BW 120 AD-5 LPG tandem drum roller in diesel, electric and liquefied petroleum gasoline (LPG) models. The LPG model has been on the trade show tour since 2019 and had a big impact with audiences at CONEXPO-CON/AGG 2020, but it’s not commercially available.

“A proposed use for LPG-powered rollers would be in areas where emissions are critical and where the exposure to exhaust particles is very limited, which is an important concern when running construction equipment. LPG burns rather clean and without any particles. In well ventilated areas, LPG can be of a benefit when the exposure to exhaust particles is of a concern or needs to be limited,” says Bert Erdmann, a product manager for Bomag Americas, Inc.

The LPG model has several benefits compared to diesel. It produces less fine dust (15%), carbon dioxide (15%) and nitrous oxide (95%) than its diesel counterpart. It is 21% more powerful compared to diesel and LPG is much cheaper (up to 40%) than diesel and gasoline. Owning and operating costs will decrease over time compared to owning a diesel machine.

Each tank of LPG can power the BW 120 AD-5 LPG for up to five hours, so users will need to make only two tank changes throughout the day — at lunch and at the start/end of the day. Changing the tank takes only five minutes.

Renewable Synthetic Diesel – Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil

Bringing alternative fuels in closer reach, Volvo Construction Equipment announced that all of its diesel-powered construction equipment can be fueled by Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil (HVO) without making any modifications to the engine.

HVO is different from other biodiesels in that it uses hydrogen — not methanol — as a catalyst. This produces propane, whereas when methanol is used as the catalyst, the product is glycerin. All oxygen is removed during the process of creating HVO and it isn’t as sensitive to heat or cold or sunlight as other biodiesels. It also performs similar to regular diesel, according to Volvo.   

Biodiesel is still more expensive than regular diesel but, since it uses the same types of tanks and pumps, switching to it is easier than many other alternative fuels, because there is no change to the process of refueling the machines.

Hydrogen-Powered Equipment

According to a report titled, The Future of Hydrogen – Seizing Today’s Opportunities, “supplying hydrogen to industrial users is now a major business around the world. Demand for hydrogen, which has grown more than threefold since 1975, continues to rise.”

Shell has released a statement that outlines a vision of the future in which 10% of total final energy consumed would come from hydrogen.

A few years ago, JCB took a majority share in ITM Power — a producer of hydrogen-creating systems. The company’s products use electrolysis to create hydrogen from water. This is often used in power-to-gas energy storage, but it can also be used in powering fuel cell electric vehicles. The company recently revealed a prototype of a hydrogen-powered excavator, equipped with a fuel cell system that is the first of its kind in the industry. It has been undergoing testing for more than a year.

Hyundai Construction Equipment announced that it is also bringing a hydrogen fuel excavator to market by 2023. According to the company, hydrogen fuel cells are more compatible with large construction equipment because of easier capacity expansion than lithium batteries (which get used in electric machines). The company also points out the superior ability of hydrogen fuel cells to expand compared to lithium ion batteries, which is a limiting factor in the ability of electric drives to power larger equipment.

Michael Brookshaw, global distribution manager for Keestrack, announced at CONEXPO-CON/AGG this year that the company is heavily investing into alternative power sources. He says Keestrack wants to put hydrogen-powered crushers onto the market, but the industry is too conservative to embrace it. At the show, he said it will be a long way down the road before we start transitioning to hydrogen.

About the Author

AEM is the North American-based international trade group representing off-road equipment manufacturers and suppliers, with more than 950 companies and more than 200 product lines in the agriculture and construction-related sectors worldwide. AEM has an ownership stake in and manages several world-class exhibitions, including CONEXPO-CON/AGG.



Discussion

Comments on this site are submitted by users and are not endorsed by nor do they reflect the views or opinions of COLE Publishing, Inc. Comments are moderated before being posted.